A Cantonese-style thick soup (now common at Hangzhou banquets) of finely minced beef and silken tofu floating in a clear cornstarch-thickened broth, finished with cilantro and egg-white drops.
Despite the name, this is not a traditional Hangzhou dish but a Cantonese soup, recorded as 蛋茸牛肉羹 (egg-and-minced-beef thick soup) in the Guangdong volume of 《中国名菜谱》around 1990. It entered Hangzhou in 1988 when the new Huanglong Hotel's restaurant brought in Cantonese cooking; because the city has West Lake and the dish is a thick soup (羹), it was simply renamed 西湖牛肉羹 — and it appears in neither the old nor the new canon of Hangzhou famous dishes. The 'looks like West Lake's still surface' explanation is one of several popular folk etymologies (others read the ripples raised by stirring, or the homophone 稀糊/西湖). The minced-beef-and-egg-white style belongs to the Jiangnan tradition of soft, clear, color-light banquet soups, distinct from northern thick mutton soups or Sichuan's spicy clears.
Hangzhou banquet starter named for the lake's pale, still surface. Mince must be hand-cut to rice-grain size — meat grinders smear fibers and cloud the broth. Egg white goes in last and below a simmer so it ribbons. Over-thicken the cornstarch and the suspension dies, beef sinks.
A pale, almost translucent bowl — the surface looks like West Lake on a still morning, with green flecks of cilantro standing in for lily pads. Texture is the whole point: every spoonful carries fine grains of beef, soft squares of tofu, and feathery egg-white threads, all suspended in broth thick enough to coat the spoon but not gluey. Pretty rather than aggressive. If the beef is in chunks or the soup is brown, it's been made wrong.
The soup lives or dies on three controls. First, the mince must be hand-cut to rice-grain size — meat grinders smear the fibers and make a paste that clouds the broth. Second, the cornstarch slurry has to coat-the-spoon thick but no thicker; over-thickening kills the suspension and the beef sinks. Third, the egg white goes in last and below a simmer, so it ribbons rather than scrambles into clouds.
Variations
Hangzhou banquet standard with cilantro and tofu; Shaoxing version adds yellow wine; modern Jiangnan banquet halls drop in conpoy threads; Cantonese siyao gengtang riffs on the same minced-protein-and-egg-white logic but with chicken.
On the Palate
Where West Lake Beef Soup sits in the Chinese flavor cloud
Ingredients
Serves 4
How it's made
6 steps · 20 min active + 5 min waiting
- 112 min
Mince 200g beef tenderloin very finely — ideally to rice-grain size — by hand with two cleavers. Marinate with 1 tsp light soy, 1 tsp Shaoxing wine, white pepper, and 1 tsp cornstarch for 10 minutes.
Watch outHand-chop the beef to rice-grain size — a grinder smears the fibers into paste that clouds the broth; you want distinct little grains.
- 23 min
Cube 200g silken tofu into 5mm dice. Soak briefly in salted hot water to firm slightly, then drain.
Watch outEnsure the water is not boiling to avoid breaking the tofu.
- 33 min
Bring 1.2L clear chicken stock to a gentle simmer. Drop the beef in pinch by pinch, stirring once with chopsticks so each grain stays separate. Skim foam.
Watch outDrop the beef in pinch by pinch into the barely-simmering stock, stirring once so each grain separates and the broth stays clear.
- 41 min
Add tofu cubes. Season with 1 tsp salt and a few drops of light soy — keep the broth pale, not brown.
- 52 min
Stream in 3 tbsp cornstarch slurry while stirring slowly — broth should thicken to a soft-coating consistency, never gluey. Then drizzle in 1 lightly beaten egg white in a thin stream while stirring; it sets into white threads.
Watch outThicken only until the broth coats the spoon-back — over-thicken and the beef sinks; then stream the egg white in below a simmer so it ribbons into threads instead of scrambling.
- 61 min
Off heat. Stir in 2 tbsp finely chopped cilantro and a few drops of sesame oil. Serve immediately in white bowls.
Archive tool suggestions — not reviewed
These legacy suggestions have not been evidence-reviewed and are not presented as required tools.
